The last section will look at what we owe to others, what a just society should ensure for its members, and whether morality requires us to treat everyone impartially. This idea was first introduced by author and philosophy professor hugh lafollette in 1980 in his article licensing parents. A reply to hugh lafollette 53 hugh lafollette, a reply to frisch final exam wednesday, may 8from 11. So instead i became a professional bagpiper and was the ships piper on the queen mary. It does not demand that we license only the best parents. Quizlet flashcards, activities and games help you improve your grades. The oldest recorded birth by the social security administration for the name lafollette is friday, september 22nd, 1905. Philosophy and public affairs, winter, 1980, 18297. In his seminal 1980 essay and a followup piece in 2010, hugh lafollette proposed that states should license all prospective parents prior to childbearing and hence childrearing so as to. One might also worry that having a parenting license is a practice akin to eugenics.
It welcomes philosophical discussions of substantive legal, social, and political problems, as well as discussions of the more abstract. Issues of public concern often have an important philosophical dimension. Hence, to prepare children for life as adults and to protect them from maltreatment, this attitude toward children must be dislodged. Not only has lafollette done an excellent job selecting seminal essays on the crucial issues, but he has lined up authors famous for their abilities to bring their deep theoretical insights to bear on everyday moral questions. As a society and culture, we justify regulating potentially harmful activities when we believe that regulating can reduce the harm.
The parental equivalent of a basic drivers exam could have revealed that nadya suleman had neither a plan to support her. Summarize hugh lafollettes argument for parental licensing, then explain one of the objections raised by one of the two critics. One 35 page paper engaging with one of the singer, thomson, lafollette, huemer, anderson, rowe or mcpherson papers assigned in class. Download acrobat reader pdf files show pagination from the original source and are easier to print. Lafollette proposed that the best way to protect children from abuse and neglect caused by their parents would be to implement parental licenses to prospective parents.
The lafollette press is your source for local news, sports, events, and information in campbell county and lafollette, tn, and the surrounding area. It is a comprehensive, extremely valuable, and indeed indispensable reference work. It is theoretically desirable, but it could not be applied in practice. Thus what began as a controversial even outrageous position may turn out more plausible than we thought. Phil 220 summer 20 moral issues university of waterloo. Essay due orlett, taking drugs very seriously week 8 may 22. More information about the assignment and evaluation metrics is available on canvas. It sounds like a good idea, but it would actually violate peoples rights.
International encyclopedia of ethics major reference works. You can leave a message using the contact form below. Although the relationship between a parent and her children is different in some respects, it is also relevantly similar to. In this essay i shall argue that the state should require all parents to be licensed. Online assignments 5, 5 points each, 25 points total. Just as we have licensing programs for anything potentially very harmful today, we should also have one for being a parent. Licensing parents is the latest scheme to have allknowing, always benevolent state bureaucrats dictate the lifelong relationships of all vulnerable beings. Week 15 parent licensing 429 hugh lafollette, licensing parents 51 lawrence e. Aug, 2010 hello, by default the print key is not there, you need to set it in the server registry only along with the required value from the table included in the article i pointed to earlier.
Once that permission card is in, student may submit this request form. Hugh lafollette has argued that we ought to require parenting licenses by relating such licenses to the general practice of licensing as well as our presentlyaccepted requirements surrounding adoption. Essays integrate ethical theory and the discussion of practical moral problems into a text that is ideal for introductory and applied ethics courses. Even this way of speaking oversimplifies our choices since there are two distinct scales on which to place alternatives. Philosophy and public affairs is founded in the belief that a philosophical examination of these issues can contribute to their clarification and to their resolution. Perhaps we should apply the same logic to biological parents that we do to adoptive parents in the hopes of preventing harms to children. Facebook gives people the power to share and makes the world more open and connected. Examples include drivers licence, medical license, attorney license, one. In his widelydiscussed article, licensing parents, hugh lafollete argues that states should require people to attain a license in order to be parents to prevent any serious harm to children. P2 an activity which meets the following three criteria is an activity which the state ought to license. That is, licensing parents could serve as an excuse to wrongly prevent minority groups from reproducing.
The oxford handbook of practical ethics oxford handbooks. The fourth edition of ethics in practice offers an impressive collection of 70 new, revised, and classic essays covering key ethical issues. We can trainteach parents to think about child bearing etc. One scale concerns the degree if at all to which guns should be abolished. The oxford handbook of practical ethics is a lively and authoritative guide to current thought about ethical issues in all areas of human activitypersonal, medical, sexual, social, political, judicial, and international, from the natural world to the world of business. The right to keep ones biological baby must be discussed anew. I argue that licensing of parents may not significantly reduce the cases of harming children caused by their parents. When was the first name lafollette first recorded in the united states. Summarize lafollette s argument about licensing parents. Because again, lafollette is not proposing that we only license good parents, merely that we do not license abominable ones. Christopher heath wellman, georgia state university. Licensing parents revisited lafollette 2010 journal. It is both theoretically desirable and practically applicable.
As a last name lafollette was the 10,866 th most popular name in 2010. Include a stamped, addressed envelope that is the appropriate size for each transcript requested. My main goal is to demonstrate that the licensing of parents is theoretically desirable, though i shall also argue that a workable and just licensing program actually could be established. In this paper we reexamine hugh lafollette s proposal that the state carefully determine the eligibility and suitability of prospective parents before granting them a license to parent. Phil response 8 response 8 contemporary moral problems. Records may include photos, original documents, family history, relatives, specific dates, locations and full names. After developing the basic rationale for the licensing of parents, i shall consider several. One 35 page paper engaging with one of the singer, thomson, lafollette, anderson, rowe or mcpherson papers assigned in class.
Lafollette argues that using the policy of parent licensing would reduce the harm inflicted to children by their parents explanation of my argument. Lafollette press 225 north first street lafollette, tn 37766. Adobe pdf documents huge print job size solutions anyone. Hugh lafollette licensing parents parents should have a license, should be like adoption process, we require driver, doctors, lawyers to all be licensed so should parents, so many kids are abused, neglected and will turn out the same. However, lafollettes proposal, as is, just picks out parents who are likely bring harm to their children. Libertarianism and parental licensing back in december of 2011, i posted licensing parents, defending a view hugh lafollette had introduced into philosophical literature in 1980. But please do not place copies of them on another server. Lafollette points out that the government currently regulates several sorts of activities by requiring a license to perform them. Btw, exceeds the stringent privacy requirements for anyone doing business with eu residents. File type icon file name description size revision time user. In this paper, i reevaluate his proposal by looking at various facts and data related to child abuse and neglect. Hugh lafollettes argument for parental licensing essay.
Raise one objection to this argument and consider how lafollette would respond to this objection, drawing on his discussion. You can be prone to distraction or substance abuse and still be a minimally competent driver, and so lafollette s proposed scheme is broadly analogous to existent licensing. Join facebook to connect with matthew lafollette and others you may know. Response 8 contemporary moral problems joncas, amanda in hugh lafollettes essay licensing parents revisited, lafollette.
Lafolette, licensing parents may 10 should parents be licensed. It sounds like a good idea, but it would actually violate peoples. Gun ownership is not a fundamental right, it is a derivative right. Mon, tues, thurs, fri 8 am to 5 pm wed 8 am to 4 pm. I will attempt to argue lafollette s point by using the different scenarios and analogies presented in his essay. Next we will look at whether drugs should be legal. Brute science, practice of ethics, the oxford handbook of practical ethics printed encyclopedias and other books with definitions for hugh lafollette. What is lafollette s considered view on licensing parents. My proposal, how ever, does not demand that we make these fine distinctions. Children subject to parents who perceive children in this way are likely to be adequately prepared for adulthood. I disagree with lafollette s claim that parents should be licensed, specifically that violators would have their child taken away from them and. The tragic consequence of not having reproductive policies for israelis with disabilities doron dorfman introduction the desire of an individual to become a parent can be very strong, especially in childcentric societies, where the idea of having children and raising a family is highly valued.
Licensing parents hugh lafollette lafollette s thesis and argument is that we should require all parents or potential parents to procure a license prior to having children. Philosopher hugh lafollette has long advocated advance screening to license parents, just as we license drivers and doctors. According to hugh lafollette in his essay licensing parents, it is and would be both right and possible to do so. Topic approved the problem of possibly inadequate parents. Mary lafollette historical records and family trees. As i have argued, licensing is a viable way to protect children. A potential solution for the staggering rates of child abuse may be parental licensing requiring a license for anybody who wishes to have andor raise a child, similar to a drivers license. Licensing parents revisited, journal of applied philosophy, 2010, 32743. Many of us assume we must either oppose or support gun control. View phil response 8 from phil 101 at university of wisconsin, parkside.
Hugh lafollette licensing parents in this essay i shall argue that the state should require all parents to be licensed. Online assignments 4, 5 points each, 20 points total. Licensing parents hugh lafollete would the licensing of parents be morally right and theoretically possible. Current student transcript release form a parent permission transcript release card must be handed in prior to this request form. Although the relationship between a parent and her children is different in some respects, it is also relevantly similar to that between a professional and those she serves. Historical records and family trees related to mary lafollette. In most modern, industrialized nations governments seek to protect their citizens by controlling potentially dangerous activities through licensing. There will be two inclass paper workshops that contribute to this grade. In the article licensing parents, hugh lafollette controversially takes licensing one step further and concludes that the state should morally require people to obtain a license before becoming parents. A reply to hugh lafollette week 7 may 15 should drugs be legal. The practice of ethics 499 like not using someone harmfully and against his will as a means for the greater good of others can permissibly be overridden when the consequences of. Smith, drugs, morality and the law may 17 should drugs be legal. Libertarianism and parental licensing bleeding heart. Lafolette, licensing parents jan 30 frisch, on licentious licensing.
24 378 1351 1268 627 372 777 1160 1302 1633 877 1639 87 47 1340 833 387 1265 830 1605 1233 1348 145 1279 1429 854 1035 705 17 834 967 389 551 343 1243